Playing with gridlines

I’ve been learning a lot about composition. While enjoying this view during a recent walk in Central Park, I started playing with the placement of the shoreline in the photo. I’m usually in favor of a lot of sky, but the deep color of the the water in the foreground seems to add more drama to the shot.

Aligned shoreline on upper third of grid.

Aligned shoreline in center third of grid.

Aligned shoreline on lower third of grid.